Precast garage vs. a solid construction

2020-09-04

If you want to store your car safe and protected, you might wonder which garage might be better - a precast garage or a solid construction? Precast garages are rather fast to build and are also a cheaper solution, in comparison to solid constructions they offer less variety when it comes to design and individuality. We want to help you with that decision and want to show you all important information about a concrete precast garage and a solid construction.

 

Solid constructions - durable and with a huge design variety

 

Solid built garages can be planned individually. They can be adapted to the circumstances of the plot as well as to the design of the rest of the house. Thanks to the individuality of planning, they are not limited to standard sizes. Therefore, it is also possible to build multiple garages next to each other as kind of double garage. Garages with custom sizes can also offer additional space or a workshop. As solid construction is usually brick built like a house, they are robust and durable. Therefore special usage cases are possible as well.

 

For example, they are also usable as basement for a terrace or can be planted like concrete garages. Apart from that they are also usable as dry storage room or workshop thanks to the good insulation.

 

The advantages of a solid construction:

 


  • all measurements are possible


 


  • solid constructions in special measurements are cheaper than precast garages in special measurements


 


  • individual designing of the garage is possible


 


  • special constructions for different sizes, forms and designs can be implemented easily


 


  • better air conditioning and therefore less humidity and mold.


 

Figure: Brick-built solid constructions offer more design varieties

 

Precast garages - fast building and relatively low costs

 

Precast garages are a cheap alternative to solid constructions. They are usually made of concrete, steel or wood and are available in different designs. To allow stable standing it is required to first build a foundation or a ground plate as a base for the garage, that avoids settling of the garage. The manufacturer of your garage can tell you which kind of soil stabilization should be chosen. Concrete precast garages are directly manufactured in one factory, therefore no installation of single parts is required. The manufacturing of concrete garages in one factory can cause cracks in walls and ceilings more easily. Therefore garages that are made of concrete require a higher effort of care. Cracks should be repaired in order to avoid damages of the structure. To avoid humidity and mold, a humidity sensor can help. The Hörmann climate interior sensor HKSI helps to control and regulate the air humidity in your garage. Excessive air humidity makes the door open automatically, when it is normal again, the door closes automatically.

 

Advantages of precast garages:

 


  • Fast production and installation


 


  • If no special measurements are required, they are cheaper than solid constructions


 


  • Short building time


 

Figure: Just as solid constructions also precast garages can be equipped with Hörmann garage doors

 

Garage doors for solid constructions and precast garages

 

Solid constructions as well as precast garages can be equipped with different types of garage doors. Hörmann offers a huge variety of solutions for both garage types from sectional doors, up and over doors and rolling doors. Before buying a garage door you have to think of which requirements you have and then make a decision for the perfect fitting garage door, that fulfills your expectations.

 

Security is also an important aspect for garages. This depends most of the time on the garage door, this is the same for both precast garages and solid constructions. Outdated garage doors or low budget garage doors most of the time offer too little protection against unwanted guests. Especially protection against lifting make sense to protect your belongings that are stored in the garage. Therefore, Hörmann offers a special automated protection against unpermitted opening of garage doors. Hörmann experts near you can give you advice and help you to find the ideal fitting garage door for you.

 

Building costs of solid constructions compared to precast solutions

 

The cost for a garage depends on the material, the kind of garage and the number of garage doors that are used. Apart from steel sheet garages a basement is required, to guarantee a stable building. For the foundation costs of 40 to 50 Euro per square meter have to be calculated, if it is built by an expert. Additionally, there will be costs for the garage door, the roof and the walls. These costs can be very different depending on the equipment. Prices of garage doors may vary depending on function and look. Additionally, there are costs for building the garage. For brick-built garages the costs might be higher compared to precast garages, because of the working costs: For building, roof building, plastering and painting prices up to 7000 Euro are possible.

 

The cost composition for garages at a glance:

 


  • foundation building (apart from steel sheet garages)


 


  • material (garage door, roof, walls)


 


  • building of the garage (manual activities)


 

In the following overview we have made a summary of the most important information for building a solid constructed garage than a precast garage made of concrete.

 


Is a building permit for the garage required?

 

Whether a building permit for building the garage is necessary depends on the location you are living in Germany. Even if there is no need to get a permit first there are different rules that building owners have to follow. These are for example:

 


  • minimum distances of the garage to the neighbors’ plot


 


  • maximum height, space of the garage


 


  • proper drive-in possibility


 

Before the construction you should inform yourself about the regulations for garage buildings in your region. In this way you can avoid nasty surprises afterwards.

 

Figure: Wide garage with a sectional garage door by Hörmann

 

Solid construction or precast garage? In the end the decision depends on what you need and which aspects are important for you. Before planning you should make a list of advantages and disadvantages. In this way you can focus on the features that are especially important for you and choose the correct type of garage.

The vision is to close all openings in China with high-tech solutions from Hörmann.